Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Later

 

Winter vacations in Bhagalpur were the most eagerly awaited days of the year for Neela and her sister Paula. Their aunt's home was always full of warmth, laughter and activity. The moment they arrived, they were welcomed into a world far removed from their everyday routine. The mornings were crisp and misty, with the winter sun slowly spreading its warmth across the courtyard. The sisters would wake up to the aroma of freshly made luchis, alur dum and steaming cups of tea.

There were cousins to play with, endless stories to exchange and little adventures to embark upon. One of the most exciting features of the house was its frequent visitors—the monkeys! They would appear on rooftops, leap across branches and occasionally make daring raids into the courtyard. Neela and Paula were fascinated by them, but also a little wary. Not so Didibhai, their aunt's daughter. She was remarkably brave and seemed completely unafraid of the mischievous creatures. While the others kept their distance, Didibhai would confront them fearlessly, shooing them away whenever they became too adventurous. The sisters watched her with a mixture of admiration and amusement.

The afternoons passed in climbing trees, chasing butterflies, playing hide-and-seek and exploring the neighbourhood. Evenings were reserved for family gatherings, stories told by the elders and occasional outings to the local markets. Their aunt would pamper them with homemade sweets and other delicacies. At night, Neela and Paula would often share a quilt, whispering secrets and giggling long after everyone else had gone to sleep.

Those winter holidays were much more than a break from school. They were filled with the warmth of family, the mischief of childhood and memories that would remain with the sisters long after they had returned home.

As the years rolled by, Neela blossomed into a beautiful young woman. She had been a good student, disciplined and graceful, with an understated elegance that came naturally to her. Hers was a distinctly Bengali beauty: large, expressive eyes, a delicate face, long dark hair, a warm complexion and a gentle, almost contemplative smile. There was something lyrical about her presence, a quiet charm that did not demand attention but invariably attracted it. She carried herself with the poise of someone brought up in a close-knit, cultured family.

Music was an integral part of her life. Neela had a lovely singing voice and was particularly fond of Rabindrasangeet. She sang in the style of Suchitra Mitra, with its characteristic depth, clarity and emotional intensity. When she sang Tagore's songs, she seemed to inhabit every word, every pause and every subtle turn of the melody. Music gave expression to feelings she otherwise kept to herself.

But life was changing. Paula had left for Canada to pursue her higher studies, and Neela missed her terribly. The sisterly companionship, the whispered conversations, the shared laughter and the little secrets that had once made up so much of her world were now reduced to occasional telephone calls and messages across continents. A familiar emptiness had crept into her otherwise comfortable existence.

And then came Aninda.

Neela fell in love with him, much to the surprise of anyone who knew her well. Aninda was hardly what one would call a conventional achiever. Academically, he was something of a disaster, a serial underperformer, a young man who seemed to have made failing an almost permanent habit. Yet he possessed a certain charm, an unconventional outlook and an infectious zest for life that Neela found irresistible. He was different from the predictable world she had always inhabited.

Their romance unfolded through shared experiences and discoveries. They watched international films, often choosing obscure European and Latin American productions that left them discussing the stories and their meanings long after the screenings were over. They attended western music concerts, losing themselves in the music and the electric atmosphere of live performances. They wandered through bookshops, spent hours talking over coffee and discovered the pleasure of simply being together. Sometimes they needed no particular destination; the journey itself was enough.

Aninda introduced Neela to a world that was spontaneous, unpredictable and exhilarating. She, in turn, brought a certain tenderness and refinement into his life. They were young, deeply attracted to each other and convinced, as young lovers often are, that the world could wait. For Neela, who had always followed the familiar rhythms of family, studies and music, love was an unexpected adventure. And she was ready to embrace it.

"How could you ever fall for him?" Didibhai asked, unable to conceal her astonishment. "Of all the people in the world, Neela, you had to choose Aninda?"

Neela burst out laughing. There was no embarrassment, no attempt to defend her choice. She simply shrugged and said, with disarming honesty, "I love the way he speaks English! He speaks so beautifully, so effortlessly. I still fumble, you know. I have to think before putting a sentence together, while he seems to have the right words ready all the time. And he is such a good reader! He reads everything—novels, essays, poetry, foreign authors. He can talk about books for hours. I find that absolutely fascinating."

Didibhai looked at her incredulously. "So that's it? Good English and a few books, and you've lost your heart?"

Neela laughed again. Perhaps she knew how ridiculous it sounded. But attraction rarely submits itself to logical examination. She was drawn to the confidence with which Aninda expressed himself, the ease of his conversation and the literary world he seemed to inhabit. He could make even an ordinary conversation sound interesting. To Neela, who had always been conscious of her own occasional hesitation with English, his fluency was almost magical.

She had fallen for his words before she had fully understood the man behind them. And, at that age, perhaps that was enough.

Life, however, had its own way of unfolding, often in directions neither of them had quite anticipated.

Neela moved through her academic life with remarkable ease. She completed her Ph.D. in Bengali without much struggle, her natural aptitude for literature, her disciplined approach and her love of the language carrying her forward. She appeared for the National Eligibility Test (NET), qualified with confidence and soon secured a lectureship. The girl who had once been fascinated by Aninda's command of English had grown into an accomplished academic herself. Her world was now one of research papers, literary criticism, university corridors, lecture halls and the timeless richness of Bengali literature. She had found her place in an intellectually stimulating environment where ideas mattered and words were weighed with precision.

Neela's academic reputation gradually began to travel beyond India. Her research papers earned her invitations to prestigious universities and academic forums in Oxford, Venice and the Sorbonne in Paris. She particularly attracted attention for an unusual comparative study in which she explored the dramatic techniques, social satire and theatrical conventions of Molière alongside those of a Bengali playwright. Her ability to draw meaningful parallels between two seemingly distant literary traditions impressed the academic community. What made her work particularly distinctive was her sensitivity to cultural nuances and her ability to demonstrate how human follies, pretensions and social contradictions transcended geographical boundaries. These invitations opened up an entirely new world for Neela, giving her an international academic identity that she had never consciously pursued but had certainly earned.

Aninda, meanwhile, had chosen an altogether different road. He was determined to make films. The journey was neither glamorous nor easy. He spent his days running errands for directors and assistant directors, carrying messages, arranging things, waiting endlessly on sets and making himself useful wherever an opportunity presented itself. He was often at the periphery of the action, watching, learning and absorbing the mechanics of filmmaking. He lived among people who spoke of camera angles, lighting, scripts, locations and the magic of the final cut. He was drawn to the energy of the film world, its unpredictability and its larger-than-life personalities. He was flamboyant, sociable and forever chasing the next opportunity. Even when he had little to show for his efforts, he carried himself with the confidence of someone who believed he was destined for something bigger.

Gradually, their worlds began to drift apart.

Neela's was becoming increasingly inward-looking, intellectual and reflective. She found satisfaction in the subtleties of language, the layers of meaning in literature and the quiet discipline of academic life. Aninda's world, by contrast, was expansive, restless and flamboyant. It revolved around people, possibilities, ambitions and the ever-changing landscape of cinema. One sought depth; the other thrived on movement. One was learning to inhabit the world of ideas; the other was trying to find his place in a world of images and spectacle.

They still had their shared memories, their films, their concerts and the romance that had once made everything seem possible. But the common ground was gradually becoming narrower. It was not necessarily a question of intelligence or ability, nor could either of them be dismissed as having chosen an inferior path. They were simply growing in different directions.

Perhaps the most unsettling part was that neither had noticed precisely when the distance had begun. What had once been an irresistible attraction was now being tested by the realities of two very different lives.

Marriage brought Neela and Aninda together under one roof, and for a while, life seemed to have settled into a rhythm of its own. Their son, Nirbaan, arrived as the most precious addition to their lives. His birth filled their home with a happiness that neither had quite experienced before. Neela, despite her academic commitments, discovered a new world in motherhood. Aninda, too, was delighted with the little boy, whose presence seemed to give a new meaning to their otherwise disparate lives.

The first two years passed in a haze of baby clothes, toys, sleepless nights, little celebrations and countless photographs. Like every parent, they watched Nirbaan grow, eagerly anticipating his first words, his first steps and the thousand little milestones that childhood promises. But gradually, Neela began noticing things that troubled her. Nirbaan was not responding to his name as consistently as she expected. He seemed unusually absorbed in his own world, often oblivious to the activity around him. He did not communicate in the way other children of his age did, and certain sounds, movements and routines appeared to hold his attention in ways she could not understand. Sometimes, she would call him repeatedly, only to find him completely engrossed in something seemingly insignificant.

At first, she tried to reassure herself. Perhaps he was simply a late talker. Perhaps every child followed a different timetable. Aninda, too, was reluctant to read too much into these observations. Yet a mother's instinct is difficult to silence. The questions accumulated, and eventually they sought professional advice.

The assessment that followed brought them face to face with a reality they had neither anticipated nor prepared themselves for. Nirbaan was a special child. He was showing developmental differences that required further understanding and support.

For Neela, the words seemed to hang in the air. She had spent years studying the intricacies of human expression, language and communication, yet here was her own child, whose little world she could not fully enter. She wondered what lay ahead, whether he would speak, whether he would understand her, whether she would ever know what was happening inside that beautiful little head.

There were tears, bewilderment and an overwhelming tenderness. But there was no question of rejection or blame. Thankfully, Neela's in-laws were wonderfully supportive. They did not add to her distress with accusations, unnecessary advice or misplaced sympathy. Instead, they stood beside the young couple, offering reassurance and affection when it was needed most.

That day, Neela and Aninda discovered something that would change their understanding of parenthood forever. Their son was different, and the journey ahead would demand a different kind of patience, courage and love.

Twenty-six years had passed since Nirbaan came into their lives. He was no longer the little boy whose first words and tentative steps Neela had waited for with such anxious anticipation. He was a grown man now, twenty-six years old, but his world remained different from the one inhabited by those around him.

And somewhere along the way, Aninda had walked out of their lives.

He had left Neela and Nirbaan for another woman, abandoning not merely a marriage but every responsibility that came with it. There were no meaningful phone calls, no visits, no enquiries, no attempts at reconciliation. He had severed every connection with the family, as though the years they had shared had been erased from his memory. The man who had once been the centre of Neela's universe had become an absence that neither explained itself nor sought forgiveness. Was it their careers hey couldn’t carry off as a couple? Was it their performances and achievements that stood in the way? Was it Nirbaan?

Neela, however, refused to let that absence define their lives.

She had grown into a woman of formidable strength and presence. Her academic accomplishments continued to flourish. Invitations, research papers, lectures and international engagements remained part of her professional life. She still travelled when required, still commanded attention in academic circles and still found immense satisfaction in her work. But behind that accomplished exterior was a mother whose life revolved around one unshakeable responsibility: Nirbaan. Through all these years, Neela's mother had been her greatest strength, standing beside her like an immovable rock. She never allowed Neela to feel that she was fighting her battles alone. While Neela spent long hours at colleges, attending lectures, presenting papers and travelling to conferences, her mother took complete charge of Nirbaan. She understood his needs, his moods and his little ways, offering him the security of an unwavering presence. Their bond was particularly endearing. Nirbaan had his own special way of addressing her; he called her "Darling". The word, uttered with his characteristic innocence, never failed to melt her heart. She would indulge him, humour him and patiently attend to his endless needs, finding joy in the smallest exchanges. For Neela, knowing that Nirbaan was in such loving hands was a priceless reassurance. Her mother had quietly become the pillar that held their little world together, allowing Neela to remain both the accomplished academic she had worked so hard to become and the devoted mother Nirbaan needed.

She had become his protector, interpreter and constant companion. She understood his silences, his peculiar rhythms, his anxieties and his small, everyday joys. She had learnt to recognise what he could not always express in words. There were days when balancing her academic commitments with his needs seemed almost impossible, but she never allowed him to feel that he was a burden. She shielded him from the indifference of the world, sometimes from its cruelty, and, above all, from the feeling that he had been abandoned.

She had not given up her own identity to become his mother. Nor had she allowed motherhood to diminish the woman she was. She had simply learnt to carry two worlds within herself: one that demanded intellectual rigour, professional excellence and public engagement, and another that required an inexhaustible reservoir of patience, tenderness and unconditional love.

It was one of those evenings when Neela could no longer keep her anxieties to herself. She was sitting with Subrata, her childhood friend, someone before whom she had never felt the need to pretend. They had known each other long enough for silence to be as meaningful as conversation.

"Subrata, do you know what frightens me most?" she began, staring absently at her cup of tea. "It isn't what will happen tomorrow, or even what will happen five years from now. It is what will happen when ma and I are no longer around."

Subrata looked at her but did not interrupt.

"Nirbaan is twenty-six. He may be an adult by the calendar, but he will always need someone to understand him, to look after him, to make sense of a world that often makes no sense to him. My mother has been my greatest support, but she too is growing older. What happens when both of us are gone? Tell me, Subrata, what happens then?"

Her voice faltered.

"Is there really anything in this country that takes care of people like Nirbaan? Not merely a place where they can be accommodated, fed and kept out of sight. I mean somewhere they can live with dignity, where somebody knows their names, understands their fears, recognises their happiness and doesn't treat them as a burden. Is there a system that will stand by them when their parents cannot?"

She paused, trying to compose herself.

"I have spent years in universities, written papers, attended conferences in Oxford, Venice and Paris, spoken about literature and the human condition. I can discuss Molière and Bengali theatre with scholars across the world. But when it comes to my own son's future, I feel utterly helpless. What good are all my degrees if I cannot answer the simplest question a mother can ask: who will look after my child when I am gone?"

The tears came before she could stop them.

Subrata leaned forward. "Neela, listen to me. You are asking a question that every parent of a child with lifelong support needs should be able to ask of society. It should not depend on how educated the parents are, how much money they have or whether they happen to know the right people. Care cannot be a privilege. It has to be a responsibility."

Neela wiped her eyes. "Beautiful words, Subrata. But where is that responsibility? Where do I find it? I don't want Nirbaan to spend the rest of his life being passed from one institution to another. I don't want him to become somebody's charitable obligation. He has feelings, preferences, little pleasures. He laughs, he remembers, he waits. Sometimes he waits for a father who has forgotten him. Must he spend the rest of his life waiting for people who may never come?"

Subrata was quiet for a moment.

"Perhaps we have been looking at the question from the wrong end," he said. "We keep asking who will take care of these children. Perhaps we should begin by asking why society has not created a world in which they can belong. Nirbaan does not need pity, Neela. He needs acceptance, continuity and security. He needs people who will see him as a person, not as a diagnosis. And he needs a future that does not disappear with yours."

"But can we build such a future?"

"Not in a day. And certainly not through promises. We need to think about supported living, trained caregivers, financial security, legal safeguards and, most importantly, a community that will not abandon him. We must make arrangements while we still have the strength to do so. Love is not only about protecting someone today. Sometimes it is about preparing the world that will receive them tomorrow."

Neela looked at him.

"I have never been afraid of hard work, Subrata. I have worked for everything I have achieved. But this is different. I cannot write a research paper on Nirbaan's future. I cannot defend it before an academic panel. I cannot even guarantee that the people who promise to care will remain."

Subrata reached for his cup.

"Then don't try to solve the rest of his life tonight. But don't give up asking the question either. And don't mistake your helplessness for failure. You have given him something no institution can provide by itself: the certainty that he is loved. Now we must find a way to make that love endure beyond your lifetime."

For a long while, neither spoke.

Outside, the evening had settled into darkness. Neela was still worried, perhaps more than before, because the questions had finally acquired words. But something had changed. For the first time, she had spoken aloud the fear she had carried silently for years.

And Subrata had not offered her consolation. He had offered her something more valuable: the possibility that Nirbaan's future could be a collective responsibility rather than a mother's solitary burden.

There was one absence she could never entirely fill.

Nirbaan still spoke of his father. Perhaps he remembered him; perhaps he had constructed an image of him from fragments of an earlier childhood. Sometimes, when Neela was occupied with her papers or preparing for a lecture, he would sit by himself, talking softly. His conversations often seemed to belong to a world where time had not moved on, where fathers did not leave and where promises were not forgotten.

Neela found Nirbaan unusually at ease with the monkeys of Bhagalpur. He would never be scared of them like he would be with friends his age. One evening, in the quiet of the house of Bhagalpur, Neela heard him speaking.

"Baba, where are you? Don't you have time to talk to me?"

There was a pause.

Then, in a voice that seemed to come from somewhere deep within his own little world, Nirbaan answered for his father.

"Later."

And the word hung in the silence.

Later.

The one word that had perhaps defined his father's absence, and the one word that Nirbaan, even at twenty-six, was still waiting to hear turn into a conversation.

I’m Never Ready

With a red shirt, I'm never ready,
But blue just shows my belly.
And yellow somehow doesn't follow,
While green makes me feel greedy.

In velvet, I can never start,
And purple breaks my heart.
Pink never leaves me steady,
While brown makes me feel needy.

In black and white, I'm never ready!

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

103, Rashbehari Avenue

 

An old man had died in his apartment at 103, Rashbehari Avenue. It was the smell that first drew the neighbourhood's attention. Mr Ghosh, aged 85, had passed away, apparently unnoticed, in the confines of his home. He was survived by two daughters, one settled in Toronto and the other in New York, and three sons, living respectively in Bangalore, Brisbane and Boston. His only companion in those final days had been Susanta, his domestic help.

Rashbehari Avenue had seen better days. Once known for its stately houses, sprawling balconies and old-world charm, The Sunday smell of Bengali cuisines, the neighbourhood had gradually surrendered to the relentless march of time. The grand houses still stood, their high ceilings, ornate staircases and weather-beaten facades bearing testimony to an age when families lived together, when three generations shared a roof, and when the sound of children playing in the courtyards was an everyday affair. Those days were gone. These magnificent houses had become monuments to loneliness. Their owners, now in their seventies and eighties, lived out their twilight years in rooms that were once filled with the laughter of children and the bustle of family life. Their sons and daughters had crossed oceans in pursuit of better opportunities, carrying with them degrees, ambitions and promises to return. They had settled in Toronto, London, New York, Melbourne and Singapore. Some sent money regularly. Others remembered birthdays and anniversaries through hurried video calls. A few visited once every two or three years, usually for a fortnight, bringing expensive gifts and leaving behind assurances that they would soon arrange something more permanent.

But time had its own arrangements.

The old parents, under the threat of local greedy promoters, learnt to manage their medicines, medical appointments, appointed nurses for help, even for eye drops for their dwindling eyesight. Domestic helps became their closest companions, sometimes their only witnesses to the gradual deterioration of their lives. Newspapers lay unread on verandas. Television sets played endlessly in otherwise silent rooms. Meals were cooked for one, and festivals that once brought entire families together were reduced to a telephone call and a photograph exchanged over WhatsApp; of course there was no dearth of messages like I love you, I miss you.

There were exceptions, of course. Some had grandchildren who occasionally visited; others had neighbours who checked on them. But even the most sociable among them carried an unspoken fear: what if something happened in the middle of the night? Who would know? Who would come?

The neighbourhood had developed an unwritten code. The milkman knew whose newspaper had not been collected. The security guard noticed which balcony lights remained switched off. The grocer knew who had stopped buying their regular provisions. And the domestic helps, who often knew more about the residents than their own children did, became the unofficial custodians of their secrets.

Deaths were not uncommon in those houses. Sometimes a relative arrived in time; sometimes the news travelled faster than the family. There were occasions when neighbours discovered that someone had been missing from their morning walks for days. Yet nothing quite prepared Rashbehari Avenue for what had happened at 103.

For Mr Ghosh had not been seen for some time. And it was not a telephone call from Toronto, New York, Bangalore, Brisbane or Boston that finally brought his fate to light.

It was the smell.

And the post-mortem revealed a chilling secret.

POST-MORTEM EXAMINATION REPORT

 

Case: Unnatural death

Name: Mr. Ghosh

Age: 85 years

Place of recovery: 103, Rashbehari Avenue, Kolkata

Date of examination: 17 November 2026

Examining authority: Department of Forensic Medicine and Toxicology

External Examination

The body was that of an elderly male, approximately 85 years of age, moderately built and poorly nourished. The body was found in an advanced state of decomposition, indicating that death had occurred several days prior to its discovery.

There was extensive greenish discolouration over the abdomen, marbling of the skin, bloating of the facial and abdominal regions, and peeling of the superficial layers of the epidermis. The characteristic features of decomposition were consistent with the reported circumstances in which the body had remained undiscovered inside a closed apartment.

No fresh external injuries, significant bruises, ligature marks or visible signs of physical assault were identified. However, the advanced decomposition limited the reliability of certain external findings.

 Internal Examination

On opening the thoracic and abdominal cavities, the internal organs showed varying degrees of decomposition. The lungs were congested, although decomposition changes prevented a definitive assessment of their condition at the time of death.

The heart showed age-related degenerative changes with moderate coronary atherosclerosis. The kidneys exhibited features consistent with chronic age-related deterioration. The liver and other abdominal organs were decomposed.

No gross evidence of penetrating trauma, major internal haemorrhage or skeletal injury was observed.

 Toxicological Examination

Samples of preserved internal organs, blood where recoverable, and gastric contents were collected and forwarded for chemical and toxicological analysis.

The results were inconclusive due to the advanced state of decomposition. No definitive opinion regarding poisoning could be offered at this stage.

Estimated Time Since Death

Based on the degree of decomposition, environmental conditions, and the circumstances in which the body was discovered, death was estimated to have occurred approximately five to seven days prior to the post-mortem examination, subject to considerable variation depending on temperature, humidity and ventilation.

Opinion

The cause of death cannot be conclusively established from the present examination owing to advanced decomposition.

The possibility of natural death due to age-related cardiovascular complications cannot be ruled out. Equally, the absence of visible external injuries does not, by itself, exclude the possibility of poisoning or other forms of unnatural death.

Final opinion is reserved pending toxicological and histopathological reports.

Confidential Investigating Officer's Note (not part of the post-mortem report):

The estimated time of death places Mr. Ghosh's death approximately six days before the discovery of his body.

This raises a significant discrepancy in the domestic help Susanta's statement that he had personally served Mr. Ghosh tea only three days before the body was discovered.

More disturbing still, preliminary bank records indicate that approximately ₹14 lakh was withdrawn from Mr. Ghosh's savings account after the estimated time of death.

These circumstances warrant further investigation.

103, Rashbehari Avenue

The Investigation

The investigation initially centred on Susanta.

He had been Mr Ghosh's closest attendant for several years. He had unrestricted access to the apartment, knew the old man's daily routine and was familiar with his banking arrangements. His statement about having served tea to Mr Ghosh three days before the discovery of the body was inconsistent with the post-mortem findings.

During interrogation, Susanta maintained that he had served tea on the day he had mentioned. He could not, however, produce any convincing explanation for the discrepancy. His mobile phone records showed that he had made several calls during the period in question, including one to an unidentified number. The police also learnt that he had recently been in financial difficulty.

The ₹14 lakh withdrawal from Mr Ghosh's savings account further strengthened the suspicion against him. Susanta was taken into custody for questioning. His fingerprints were easily recovered from several objects in the apartment, including the cup and saucer found beside Mr Ghosh's bed. His access to the house and his knowledge of the old man's financial affairs became important points in the police case.

The investigation, however, did not stop there.

The bank withdrawal was examined more closely. The transaction had been authorised through credentials that could not be traced to Susanta. The account activity revealed a connection with a mobile number registered in the name of Mr Ghosh's son, who lived in Boston.

The police contacted the bank and obtained the relevant transaction records. They also examined the apartment's security footage, the building's visitor register and the call records of the family members.

A name began to emerge repeatedly: a local property promoter who had been negotiating for the acquisition of the property at 103, Rashbehari Avenue.

The promoter had approached Mr Ghosh several times. The old man had refused to sell hoping that his family would be reunited.. The property, with its considerable land value and location on Rashbehari Avenue beside Priya Cinema Hall had attracted considerable interest from developers. The promoter's earlier visits had been recorded in the building's visitor register.

Further examination of telephone records established contact between the promoter and Mr Ghosh's son in Boston. Their conversations had begun several weeks before Mr Ghosh's death.

A financial trail provided the next piece of evidence. A substantial sum had been transferred to an intermediary associated with the promoter shortly before the estimated date of death. The intermediary's subsequent movements, corroborated by CCTV footage and telephone records, placed him near 103, Rashbehari Avenue during the relevant period.

The police reconstructed the events.

Mr Ghosh's son had approached the promoter with a specific request: his father had to be removed from the property. The promoter arranged for two men to enter the apartment. Mr Ghosh died before his body was discovered. The precise manner of death remained subject to forensic investigation.

The subsequent withdrawal of ₹14 lakh was traced to instructions originating from the son's side. The transaction had been arranged after Mr Ghosh's death, using access to his banking credentials.

Susanta's involvement had been constructed around his ordinary duties. His presence in the apartment, his fingerprints on household objects, his knowledge of Mr Ghosh's affairs and his statement about the last cup of tea had all provided the material for suspicion to settle on him.

The call that the police had initially considered suspicious was eventually identified as a communication with an intermediary connected to the promoter. Susanta had been contacted and instructed to maintain that he had served Mr Ghosh tea three days before the discovery. He had repeated the account without knowing the full sequence of events.

When confronted with the financial records and telephone evidence, the promoter's intermediary disclosed the arrangement. The promoter was subsequently detained. The son in Boston was named as the principal conspirator, and the police initiated the process of securing his return to India.

Susanta's statement was reviewed in the light of the new evidence. His fingerprints and access to the apartment no longer established his participation in the death.

At 103, Rashbehari Avenue, the old man's body had remained undiscovered for nearly a week. During those days, his bank account had been accessed, money had changed hands, and the first suspect had been identified long before the investigation had established who had arranged the death.

The case was reopened with the son, the promoter and the intermediary at its centre.

 The Final Chapter

 

A few weeks later, all five children gathered at 103, Rashbehari Avenue. For the first time in years, the house was filled with their voices. The two daughters had arrived from Toronto and New York, while the brothers had come from Bangalore and Brisbane. The youngest, from Boston, was no longer free to join them. He was in judicial custody, facing charges in connection with his father's death.

The investigation had established his role in the conspiracy, the engagement of the promoter and the arrangements that had led to their father's death. The promoter and his associates were also facing prosecution.

The remaining siblings sat together in the drawing room. The same room where their father had spent countless afternoons reading newspapers, listening to the radio and waiting for telephone calls that rarely came. There were no elaborate speeches.

-        Killing my own father! Paptu? How!

-        Really? The blame is on him, is it? Like Paptu did it, he ate my food, he broke my pencil? Remember? We are all guilty of killing our father in the hands of loneliness.

Their faces hung in shame. They spoke of their childhood, the house, their parents and the years that had passed. They also spoke of the events that had brought them together under such circumstances.

Eventually, they reached a decision.

None of them wished to claim the property for themselves. After completing the necessary legal formalities, they unanimously decided to transfer 103, Rashbehari Avenue to an NGO committed to the education of underprivileged children. The building would be redeveloped into a school, providing free education and opportunities to children who might otherwise never have access to them.

The school would bear their father's name.

Ghosh Memorial School.

The inauguration took place the following year. The old balconies and weather-beaten walls had given way to classrooms, a library and a playground. Children filled the corridors with the sounds that the house had not heard for decades.

On the entrance wall was a modest plaque:

Ghosh Memorial School

Dedicated to the memory of Mr Ghosh

In the service of real education for all.

 

The children stood before it for a while. Then they walked into the school, where a new generation had already begun its lessons.

103, Rashbehari Avenue was no longer a house waiting for someone to return.

It had become a place where children could begin their future.

Every morning, as the children assembled for their prayers, their voices echoed through the building:

O dear God,
Help us to be good,
In the games we play,
Or the work we do.

And so, in a house where an old man had once waited in vain for the sound of his children's footsteps, the laughter and prayers of hundreds of children would now be heard every morning.

The Doors are Locked

 The doors are closed.

Not locked, perhaps,
but there is nowhere left to go.

We sit across face to face,
rehearsing our explanations,
mistaking them for truths.

Outside, life continues.
Inside, we remain—
each imprisoned by the other's gaze,
and more so by our own.

There are the keys,
Yet there is no exit.

Only the company
of everything we have been.

They Come and Go

 


They come and go
Leaves
Pages
Memories
Effortlessly, endlessly

The day falls into darkness,
then into dawn,

And freshness is reborn.
Balmy summer
Bracing winter
Breezy golden autumn
Blooming fragrant spring

From old to new,
No one says farewell,
None says adieu.
It turns like a wheel,
An invisible cycle,
The most enduring,
The most tangible of truths.
The curtains fall and rise,
With certainty, without surprise.

Yet we hardly ever see
The leaves
The pages
The memories
Appearing in the night,
Disappearing with the sunrise. 

Saturday, November 14, 2026

কেন আমায়

কেন আমায় ফেলে রেখে যাস

ওরে আমার যত প্রিয়জন

কত খোঁজা হল সারা 

শেষ হল না জেতা হারা 

হলাম আমি দিশেহারা 

তবু পেলাম না হায় তোদের দর্শন 

যতই আমি বেড়াই ঘুরে 

প্রাচীন ধূসর দেওয়াল ধরে 

সুদুর মাঠে নদীর পাড়ে 

পাই না রে সেই ফেলে আসা 

মনোরম জীবন । 

যখন আমি দুচোখ বুজি 

মনের মধ্যে তোদের খুঁজি 

ধরা দিস রে সবাই তোরা 

আনন্দে হই আত্মহারা 

অশ্রু ঝরে অনুক্ষণ।

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

The Wounds

  

Kolkata is a city that never quite learns to be quiet. It is a place where history, tradition and modern life mingle in a fascinating medley. Known as the cultural capital of India, it has an unmistakable personality of its own. Grand colonial buildings stand beside modern glass-fronted offices; narrow lanes open into broad tree-lined avenues; and yellow Ambassador taxis, buses, auto-rickshaws and private cars compete for space on its busy roads. The air is often filled with the sounds of honking horns, street vendors calling out their wares, bicycle bells and animated conversations.

There is something wonderfully distinctive about Kolkata's street life. The aroma of freshly brewed tea, served in tiny earthen cups known as bhar or bhaar, mingles with the irresistible smell of telebhaja (deep-fried savoury snacks) and freshly prepared phuchka (crisp, hollow puris filled with spicy tamarind water). Bookshops, roadside stalls, old-fashioned sweet shops and bustling markets give the city a character that is difficult to find elsewhere. Beneath its apparent chaos lies a city that loves its literature, music, theatre, food and leisurely conversations.

South Kolkata, however, has its own distinctive charm. Southern Avenue, with its broad roads, elegant residential buildings and magnificent avenues of trees, offers a relatively peaceful contrast to the crowded commercial districts. The neighbourhood has an air of understated sophistication, with old houses, apartment blocks, small cafés and shops existing side by side. Along this avenue lies Rabindra Sarobar, one of the city's most cherished green retreats.

Gunja, an eight-year-old girl, lived with her mother, a government servant, and her father, a businessman. One pleasant afternoon, she accompanied her home tutor, Malini, to Rabindra Sarobar for some outdoor play after their lessons.

The entrance to the park offered a refreshing change from the busy avenue. The moment they stepped inside, Gunja felt as though she had entered a different world. The sounds of traffic became muffled, replaced by the rustling of leaves, the chirping of birds and the occasional call of a koel. Towering rain trees, their branches spreading like enormous green umbrellas, provided generous shade. Sunlight filtered through the foliage, creating shifting patterns of gold and green on the pathways.

The lake was the heart of Rabindra Sarobar. Its vast expanse of water reflected the sky, the trees and the occasional passing cloud. The surface glistened in the afternoon light, occasionally disturbed by ripples caused by fish or waterbirds. In the distance, rowers practised their strokes, their long boats cutting through the water in graceful, rhythmic movements. A few birds stood motionless near the water's edge, while others skimmed the surface before disappearing among the trees.

One of the most interesting sights for Gunja was the elderly population that frequented the park. They seemed to have made it their second home. Some senior citizens walked slowly along the shaded pathways, supporting themselves with walking sticks. Others occupied the benches, enjoying the breeze and the familiar surroundings. A few sat with their eyes closed, practising meditation, while others performed gentle stretching exercises. Their silver hair, measured steps and unhurried movements gave the park a certain dignity. Some appeared deeply absorbed in their thoughts, while others simply watched the world go by. For them, the park was more than a place for exercise; it was a daily ritual, a meeting place with nature and perhaps a refuge from the loneliness that sometimes accompanies old age.

Gunja watched them with curiosity. She wondered how many mornings they had spent walking beneath these very trees and how many seasons they had witnessed from the same benches.

Malini found a comfortable place to sit while Gunja wandered towards the children's play area. The swings, slides and open spaces seemed to invite her to forget everything else. She ran about with the uninhibited enthusiasm of an eight-year-old, her shoes crunching over the dry leaves scattered along the path. Every now and then, she turned towards Malini to make sure she was still within sight.

As the afternoon advanced, the light began to change. The sun descended behind the buildings, and the lake acquired a golden sheen. The leaves stirred in the evening breeze, and the shadows of the trees grew longer. Outside the park, Southern Avenue continued with its familiar urban rhythm, but within its green boundaries, time seemed to move more slowly.

For a foreign visitor, Rabindra Sarobar would offer a glimpse of a side of India that might otherwise remain unnoticed. It was neither a monument nor a carefully curated tourist attraction. It was an intimate part of everyday Kolkata, where the young came to play, the elderly came to find companionship, and nature offered everyone a little respite from the demands of city life.

Gunja loved the park for its swings, trees and lake. Malini perhaps appreciated its tranquillity. But Rabindra Sarobar had something for everyone. It was a little piece of breathing space in a city that was always on the move.

The sun had begun to dip behind the trees, casting long, distorted shadows across the pathways of Rabindra Sarobar. Gunja, who had been busy exploring the playground, suddenly turned towards the bench where Malini had been sitting.

It was empty.

She looked around. Perhaps Malini had moved to another bench. Gunja ran towards the lake, scanning the familiar faces, but Malini was nowhere to be seen.

"Malini!" she called.

There was no answer.

She hurried back to the bench. Malini's handbag was gone too.

A strange uneasiness crept over her. She walked towards the entrance, hoping to find her tutor waiting there. But the park seemed suddenly enormous. The trees that had looked friendly only minutes ago now appeared dark and forbidding. The pathways seemed to twist endlessly, and every passing stranger looked unfamiliar.

"Malini! Where are you?" Her voice trembled.

She tried to retrace her steps but soon realised that she no longer knew which direction led to the entrance. The evening crowd was thinning. The elderly walkers had begun returning home, and the children's laughter was gradually fading. The shadows grew longer, swallowing the pathways one by one.

Gunja began to cry.

A little later, a police patrol noticed a small girl standing alone near one of the park's exits. Her eyes were swollen, her face streaked with tears, and she was clutching the strap of her little backpack.

"Where are your parents, little one?" one of the policemen asked gently.

Gunja could barely speak.

"My tutor... Malini... she was here. Now I can't find her."

The policemen exchanged a quick glance.

"Don't worry. We will help you find her."

They took her to the nearby police station, where she was given a glass of water and made to sit comfortably. She told how she came to the park. An officer began asking her questions.

"What is your name?"

"Gunja."

"How old are you?"

"Eight."

"And what is your tutor's name?"

"Malini."

The officer wrote down the details. Then he asked the question that made Gunja burst into tears again.

"Did you see anyone taking Malini away?"

Gunja shook her head.

Outside, the evening traffic roared along Southern Avenue. Inside the police station, the little girl sat silently, waiting for someone to tell her that everything was all right.

But Malini was missing.

And nobody knew where she had gone.

The news of Gunja's disappearance reached Malini's parents within an hour. Panic-stricken, they rushed to the police station to lodge a missing-person complaint. They had been calling Malini repeatedly, but her mobile phone remained switched off. They entered the station in a state of utter desperation, only to find their daughter standing before them.

"Gunja!"

 

Her mother rushed forward and embraced her, but Gunja was unable to respond. For a moment, her parents could hardly believe their eyes. Their daughter had been found, but the circumstances were far from reassuring. The police began questioning them, trying to establish what had happened at the park.

The following morning, a horrifying discovery sent shockwaves through the locality. Malini's body was found floating in the lake at Rabindra Sarobar. The police recovered her mobile phone from the vicinity, an important piece of evidence that could perhaps shed light on the mysterious events of the previous evening.

The news spread like wildfire. What had begun as the disappearance of a young tutor had turned into a suspected case of unnatural death. Residents of Southern Avenue were stunned. The park, which had always been associated with morning walks, leisurely afternoons and peaceful encounters with nature, suddenly became the centre of an unsettling mystery. Questions multiplied. How had Malini drowned? Why had she disappeared? What had happened to Gunja?

At home, Nandini, Gunja's mother, was struggling to make sense of her daughter's confused recollections. She had been relieved to have Gunja back, but something about the child's behaviour troubled her. While helping her change, Nandini noticed bruises around Gunja's genital area.

Her heart missed a beat.

She examined the marks more carefully, her hands trembling. They were not ordinary scratches or bruises that a child might sustain while playing.

"Gunja, does anything hurt?"

The little girl looked at her mother without answering.

Nandini felt a cold wave of dread pass through her. Malini was dead, Gunja had been found alone, and now there were unexplained injuries on her daughter's body.

She knew this was no longer simply a case of a missing tutor or an accidental drowning.

Something terrible had happened at Rabindra Sarobar.

Malini's parents arrived at Nandini's house in a state of utter devastation. Their faces were swollen from crying, their eyes bloodshot, and their bodies seemed almost incapable of bearing the weight of their grief. The sudden and inexplicable death of their only daughter had shattered their world. Balaka, Malini's mother, could barely stand without support. She clutched Nandini's hands and broke down.

"Why? Why did this happen to my child?" she sobbed. "She was so young. She had her whole life ahead of her!"

Nandini tried to console her, but words seemed terribly inadequate. The two mothers sat together, united by grief, fear and a growing sense that something sinister lay beneath the tragedy.

After a while, Balaka asked to speak to Nandini privately.

"I need to tell you something," she said, wiping her tears. "Something I should perhaps have told you earlier."

Nandini looked at her anxiously.

Balaka took a deep breath. Her voice trembled as she began.

"Malini had told me that Rajesh had been making advances towards her. Your husband, Nandini. She said he had been behaving inappropriately, making personal remarks and trying to get close to her. He was unnecessarily present when she came to their house and made advances. Gunja’s mom was always absent. She was uncomfortable, frightened even, but she didn't want to create trouble in your family. She had asked me not to tell anyone."

Nandini stared at her, unable to comprehend what she had just heard.

"Rajesh?" she whispered.

Balaka nodded, tears streaming down her cheeks.

"She was afraid of losing her job. She was afraid of what might happen if she spoke openly. I begged her to leave the tutoring assignment, but she insisted that she could handle it."

For a long moment, Nandini remained motionless. The revelation had transformed her understanding of the tragedy. The death of Malini was no longer merely a mysterious drowning, and the bruises on Gunja's body had suddenly acquired a terrifying significance.

Just then, there was a knock at the door. A young woman entered, her face tense and her eyes swollen with grief. It was Rupasri, Malini's closest friend. She had heard about Malini's death and had come to meet Nandini.

After exchanging a few words of condolence, Rupasri asked if she could speak to Nandini privately. Balaka nodded, sensing that there was something important she wanted to disclose.

"I knew about Rajesh's behaviour towards Malini," Rupasri began. "She had told me everything. He had been making advances towards her for some time. She was deeply uncomfortable, but she was afraid of confronting him."

Nandini felt her stomach tighten.

"But there is something else," Rupasri continued, her voice growing unsteady. "Something much more disturbing."

She paused, struggling to control her anger.

"On one occasion, I witnessed Rajesh touching Gunja's private parts. I was horrified. I couldn't believe what I was seeing. I confronted him immediately and told him that if I ever saw him doing anything like that again, I would tell you everything to Nandini. I warned him that I would not remain silent."

Nandini went pale.

"Why didn't you tell me then?" she whispered.

"I should have," Rupasri replied, her eyes filling with tears. "I thought my warning would be enough. I thought he would stop. I never imagined things could reach this point."

The room fell silent. Outside, the familiar sounds of Southern Avenue continued, but inside Nandini's home, an unbearable truth was beginning to emerge.

Nandini could no longer contain herself. Balaka's revelation and Rupasri's testimony had brought together pieces of a horrifying puzzle. But the bruises on Gunja's body continued to haunt her. That evening, when Rajesh returned home, she confronted him.

"Rajesh, I want an explanation. What happened to Gunja?"

Rajesh looked up from his phone. "What are you talking about?"

"Don't pretend you don't understand. I found bruises on her private parts. Rupasri has told me what she witnessed. And now Malini is dead. Do you expect me to believe all this is a coincidence?"

His expression changed. For a fleeting moment, Nandini noticed something resembling fear in his eyes.

"You're listening to other people's nonsense," he snapped. "Don't drag me into this."

"Then explain the bruises! Explain why Malini was frightened of you!"

Rajesh got up abruptly. "You'd better stop this nonsense, Nandini. You have no idea what you're getting into."

His response frightened her more than any confession could have. She quietly stepped away, determined that Gunja would never again be left alone with him.

The following day, Nandini approached the police and shared everything she had learnt. Rupasri's statement, Balaka's account of Malini's complaints and the suspicious injuries on Gunja became crucial leads. Nandini also described Rajesh's threatening response when confronted.

For the investigating officers, this was a significant breakthrough. The statements provided a possible motive for Malini's murder and a reason to investigate Rajesh's movements and communications.

The police examined Malini's recovered mobile phone, scrutinised call records and traced financial transactions and communications connected with Rajesh. What emerged was chilling.

The investigation revealed that Rajesh had hired a contract killer to eliminate Malini. He had apparently feared that she might expose his behaviour and destroy the carefully constructed respectability of his family life. The evidence of their communications and the financial trail helped establish the connection.

The police arrested Rajesh on charges relating to Malini's murder. The man allegedly hired to carry out the killing was also traced and taken into custody.

But the investigation did not end there.

Following Nandini's complaint and Rupasri's testimony, the police initiated a separate investigation into the suspected sexual abuse of Gunja. Her injuries were documented, and she was referred for a sensitive medical examination by qualified professionals. A child-protection specialist was also involved to ensure that her statement was recorded without causing further trauma.

Rajesh now faced not only charges connected with Malini's murder but also allegations of sexually abusing his own daughter.

The man who had once appeared to be a respectable businessman had become the principal accused in a case that had shaken Southern Avenue to its core.

And for Nandini, the most devastating discovery was that the danger to her little daughter had come from within her own home.

Rabindra Sarobar remained where it had always been, nestled in the heart of Southern Avenue, its sprawling trees stretching their branches towards the sky, its lake reflecting the changing colours of the day. The morning walkers returned, the joggers resumed their familiar routes, and the elderly citizens occupied their favourite benches. Some walked slowly along the pathways, their walking sticks tapping gently against the ground; others sat gazing at the water, lost in memories that belonged to another time.

The koel still called from the branches. Squirrels still darted across the tree trunks. The waterbirds continued to skim the surface of the lake, leaving delicate ripples behind them. The boats moved across the water, their oars dipping rhythmically, as though nothing had disturbed the timeless tranquillity of the place.

 

Yet something had changed.

The lake, once a shimmering expanse of blue and gold, now held a terrible secret. The pathways where children had run and laughed seemed strangely desolate. The benches beneath the rain trees, where old men and women had spent countless peaceful afternoons, appeared to carry the weight of an unspoken sorrow.

Kolkata has always been a city of contradictions. It can be noisy and tender, chaotic and contemplative, vibrant and melancholic. Its people have learnt to live with its crowded streets, its relentless traffic and its unpredictable rhythms. But Rabindra Sarobar had always offered them a refuge, a place where the city seemed to pause and breathe.

Now, for Nandini, the sight of the lake would forever summon memories she could never erase. She would remember the afternoon when she had entrusted her little daughter to Malini, the disappearance, the desperate search and the dreadful revelations that followed.

The trees would continue to blossom with the seasons. The krishnachura (flame-of-the-forest) would set the avenue ablaze with its scarlet flowers, and the shiuli (night-flowering jasmine) would scatter its delicate white blossoms on the ground when autumn arrived. Children would continue to play, lovers would stroll along the pathways, and senior citizens would return to their familiar benches.

Life, as always, would go on.

But beneath the beauty of Rabindra Sarobar lay a silence that no birdsong could dispel. The lake had witnessed an afternoon of innocence turn into a nightmare. And perhaps its greatest tragedy was that, while the city would eventually forget the headlines, a little girl would have to live with the memories.

The water would become still again. The wounds would not.