Winter vacations in Bhagalpur were the most
eagerly awaited days of the year for Neela and her sister Paula. Their aunt's
home was always full of warmth, laughter and activity. The moment they arrived,
they were welcomed into a world far removed from their everyday routine. The
mornings were crisp and misty, with the winter sun slowly spreading its warmth
across the courtyard. The sisters would wake up to the aroma of freshly made
luchis, alur dum and steaming cups of tea.
There were cousins to play with, endless
stories to exchange and little adventures to embark upon. One of the most
exciting features of the house was its frequent visitors—the monkeys! They
would appear on rooftops, leap across branches and occasionally make daring
raids into the courtyard. Neela and Paula were fascinated by them, but also a
little wary. Not so Didibhai, their aunt's daughter. She was remarkably brave
and seemed completely unafraid of the mischievous creatures. While the others
kept their distance, Didibhai would confront them fearlessly, shooing them away
whenever they became too adventurous. The sisters watched her with a mixture of
admiration and amusement.
The afternoons passed in climbing trees,
chasing butterflies, playing hide-and-seek and exploring the neighbourhood.
Evenings were reserved for family gatherings, stories told by the elders and
occasional outings to the local markets. Their aunt would pamper them with
homemade sweets and other delicacies. At night, Neela and Paula would often
share a quilt, whispering secrets and giggling long after everyone else had
gone to sleep.
Those winter holidays were much more than a
break from school. They were filled with the warmth of family, the mischief of
childhood and memories that would remain with the sisters long after they had
returned home.
As the years rolled by, Neela blossomed into
a beautiful young woman. She had been a good student, disciplined and graceful,
with an understated elegance that came naturally to her. Hers was a distinctly
Bengali beauty: large, expressive eyes, a delicate face, long dark hair, a warm
complexion and a gentle, almost contemplative smile. There was something
lyrical about her presence, a quiet charm that did not demand attention but
invariably attracted it. She carried herself with the poise of someone brought
up in a close-knit, cultured family.
Music was an integral part of her life. Neela
had a lovely singing voice and was particularly fond of Rabindrasangeet. She
sang in the style of Suchitra Mitra, with its characteristic depth, clarity and
emotional intensity. When she sang Tagore's songs, she seemed to inhabit every
word, every pause and every subtle turn of the melody. Music gave expression to
feelings she otherwise kept to herself.
But life was changing. Paula had left for
Canada to pursue her higher studies, and Neela missed her terribly. The
sisterly companionship, the whispered conversations, the shared laughter and
the little secrets that had once made up so much of her world were now reduced
to occasional telephone calls and messages across continents. A familiar
emptiness had crept into her otherwise comfortable existence.
And then came Aninda.
Neela fell in love with him, much to the
surprise of anyone who knew her well. Aninda was hardly what one would call a
conventional achiever. Academically, he was something of a disaster, a serial
underperformer, a young man who seemed to have made failing an almost permanent
habit. Yet he possessed a certain charm, an unconventional outlook and an
infectious zest for life that Neela found irresistible. He was different from
the predictable world she had always inhabited.
Their romance unfolded through shared
experiences and discoveries. They watched international films, often choosing
obscure European and Latin American productions that left them discussing the
stories and their meanings long after the screenings were over. They attended western
music concerts, losing themselves in the music and the electric atmosphere of
live performances. They wandered through bookshops, spent hours talking over
coffee and discovered the pleasure of simply being together. Sometimes they
needed no particular destination; the journey itself was enough.
Aninda introduced Neela to a world that was
spontaneous, unpredictable and exhilarating. She, in turn, brought a certain
tenderness and refinement into his life. They were young, deeply attracted to
each other and convinced, as young lovers often are, that the world could wait.
For Neela, who had always followed the familiar rhythms of family, studies and
music, love was an unexpected adventure. And she was ready to embrace it.
"How could you ever fall for him?"
Didibhai asked, unable to conceal her astonishment. "Of all the people in
the world, Neela, you had to choose Aninda?"
Neela burst out laughing. There was no
embarrassment, no attempt to defend her choice. She simply shrugged and said,
with disarming honesty, "I love the way he speaks English! He speaks so
beautifully, so effortlessly. I still fumble, you know. I have to think before
putting a sentence together, while he seems to have the right words ready all
the time. And he is such a good reader! He reads everything—novels, essays,
poetry, foreign authors. He can talk about books for hours. I find that
absolutely fascinating."
Didibhai looked at her incredulously. "So
that's it? Good English and a few books, and you've lost your heart?"
Neela laughed again. Perhaps she knew how ridiculous
it sounded. But attraction rarely submits itself to logical examination. She
was drawn to the confidence with which Aninda expressed himself, the ease of
his conversation and the literary world he seemed to inhabit. He could make
even an ordinary conversation sound interesting. To Neela, who had always been
conscious of her own occasional hesitation with English, his fluency was almost
magical.
She had fallen for his words before she had fully
understood the man behind them. And, at that age, perhaps that was enough.
Life, however, had its own way of unfolding,
often in directions neither of them had quite anticipated.
Neela moved through her academic life with
remarkable ease. She completed her Ph.D. in Bengali without much struggle, her
natural aptitude for literature, her disciplined approach and her love of the
language carrying her forward. She appeared for the National Eligibility Test
(NET), qualified with confidence and soon secured a lectureship. The girl who
had once been fascinated by Aninda's command of English had grown into an
accomplished academic herself. Her world was now one of research papers,
literary criticism, university corridors, lecture halls and the timeless
richness of Bengali literature. She had found her place in an intellectually
stimulating environment where ideas mattered and words were weighed with precision.
Neela's academic reputation gradually began
to travel beyond India. Her research papers earned her invitations to
prestigious universities and academic forums in Oxford, Venice and the Sorbonne
in Paris. She particularly attracted attention for an unusual comparative study
in which she explored the dramatic techniques, social satire and theatrical
conventions of Molière alongside those of a Bengali playwright. Her ability to
draw meaningful parallels between two seemingly distant literary traditions
impressed the academic community. What made her work particularly distinctive
was her sensitivity to cultural nuances and her ability to demonstrate how
human follies, pretensions and social contradictions transcended geographical
boundaries. These invitations opened up an entirely new world for Neela, giving
her an international academic identity that she had never consciously pursued
but had certainly earned.
Aninda, meanwhile, had chosen an altogether
different road. He was determined to make films. The journey was neither
glamorous nor easy. He spent his days running errands for directors and
assistant directors, carrying messages, arranging things, waiting endlessly on
sets and making himself useful wherever an opportunity presented itself. He was
often at the periphery of the action, watching, learning and absorbing the
mechanics of filmmaking. He lived among people who spoke of camera angles,
lighting, scripts, locations and the magic of the final cut. He was drawn to
the energy of the film world, its unpredictability and its larger-than-life
personalities. He was flamboyant, sociable and forever chasing the next
opportunity. Even when he had little to show for his efforts, he carried
himself with the confidence of someone who believed he was destined for
something bigger.
Gradually, their worlds began to drift apart.
Neela's was becoming increasingly
inward-looking, intellectual and reflective. She found satisfaction in the
subtleties of language, the layers of meaning in literature and the quiet
discipline of academic life. Aninda's world, by contrast, was expansive,
restless and flamboyant. It revolved around people, possibilities, ambitions
and the ever-changing landscape of cinema. One sought depth; the other thrived
on movement. One was learning to inhabit the world of ideas; the other was
trying to find his place in a world of images and spectacle.
They still had their shared memories, their
films, their concerts and the romance that had once made everything seem
possible. But the common ground was gradually becoming narrower. It was not
necessarily a question of intelligence or ability, nor could either of them be
dismissed as having chosen an inferior path. They were simply growing in
different directions.
Perhaps the most unsettling part was that
neither had noticed precisely when the distance had begun. What had once been
an irresistible attraction was now being tested by the realities of two very different
lives.
Marriage brought Neela and Aninda together
under one roof, and for a while, life seemed to have settled into a rhythm of
its own. Their son, Nirbaan, arrived as the most precious addition to their
lives. His birth filled their home with a happiness that neither had quite
experienced before. Neela, despite her academic commitments, discovered a new
world in motherhood. Aninda, too, was delighted with the little boy, whose
presence seemed to give a new meaning to their otherwise disparate lives.
The first two years passed in a haze of baby
clothes, toys, sleepless nights, little celebrations and countless photographs.
Like every parent, they watched Nirbaan grow, eagerly anticipating his first
words, his first steps and the thousand little milestones that childhood
promises. But gradually, Neela began noticing things that troubled her. Nirbaan
was not responding to his name as consistently as she expected. He seemed
unusually absorbed in his own world, often oblivious to the activity around
him. He did not communicate in the way other children of his age did, and
certain sounds, movements and routines appeared to hold his attention in ways
she could not understand. Sometimes, she would call him repeatedly, only to
find him completely engrossed in something seemingly insignificant.
At first, she tried to reassure herself.
Perhaps he was simply a late talker. Perhaps every child followed a different
timetable. Aninda, too, was reluctant to read too much into these observations.
Yet a mother's instinct is difficult to silence. The questions accumulated, and
eventually they sought professional advice.
The assessment that followed brought them
face to face with a reality they had neither anticipated nor prepared
themselves for. Nirbaan was a special child. He was showing developmental
differences that required further understanding and support.
For Neela, the words seemed to hang in the
air. She had spent years studying the intricacies of human expression, language
and communication, yet here was her own child, whose little world she could not
fully enter. She wondered what lay ahead, whether he would speak, whether he would
understand her, whether she would ever know what was happening inside that
beautiful little head.
There were tears, bewilderment and an
overwhelming tenderness. But there was no question of rejection or blame.
Thankfully, Neela's in-laws were wonderfully supportive. They did not add to
her distress with accusations, unnecessary advice or misplaced sympathy.
Instead, they stood beside the young couple, offering reassurance and affection
when it was needed most.
That day, Neela and Aninda discovered something
that would change their understanding of parenthood forever. Their son was
different, and the journey ahead would demand a different kind of patience,
courage and love.
Twenty-six years had passed since Nirbaan
came into their lives. He was no longer the little boy whose first words and
tentative steps Neela had waited for with such anxious anticipation. He was a
grown man now, twenty-six years old, but his world remained different from the
one inhabited by those around him.
And somewhere along the way, Aninda had
walked out of their lives.
He had left Neela and Nirbaan for another
woman, abandoning not merely a marriage but every responsibility that came with
it. There were no meaningful phone calls, no visits, no enquiries, no attempts
at reconciliation. He had severed every connection with the family, as though
the years they had shared had been erased from his memory. The man who had once
been the centre of Neela's universe had become an absence that neither
explained itself nor sought forgiveness. Was it their careers hey couldn’t
carry off as a couple? Was it their performances and achievements that stood in
the way? Was it Nirbaan?
Neela, however, refused to let that absence
define their lives.
She had grown into a woman of formidable
strength and presence. Her academic accomplishments continued to flourish.
Invitations, research papers, lectures and international engagements remained
part of her professional life. She still travelled when required, still
commanded attention in academic circles and still found immense satisfaction in
her work. But behind that accomplished exterior was a mother whose life
revolved around one unshakeable responsibility: Nirbaan. Through all these
years, Neela's mother had been her greatest strength, standing beside her like
an immovable rock. She never allowed Neela to feel that she was fighting her
battles alone. While Neela spent long hours at colleges, attending lectures,
presenting papers and travelling to conferences, her mother took complete
charge of Nirbaan. She understood his needs, his moods and his little ways,
offering him the security of an unwavering presence. Their bond was
particularly endearing. Nirbaan had his own special way of addressing her; he
called her "Darling". The word, uttered with his characteristic
innocence, never failed to melt her heart. She would indulge him, humour him
and patiently attend to his endless needs, finding joy in the smallest
exchanges. For Neela, knowing that Nirbaan was in such loving hands was a
priceless reassurance. Her mother had quietly become the pillar that held their
little world together, allowing Neela to remain both the accomplished academic
she had worked so hard to become and the devoted mother Nirbaan needed.
She had become his protector, interpreter and
constant companion. She understood his silences, his peculiar rhythms, his
anxieties and his small, everyday joys. She had learnt to recognise what he
could not always express in words. There were days when balancing her academic
commitments with his needs seemed almost impossible, but she never allowed him
to feel that he was a burden. She shielded him from the indifference of the
world, sometimes from its cruelty, and, above all, from the feeling that he had
been abandoned.
She had not given up her own identity to
become his mother. Nor had she allowed motherhood to diminish the woman she
was. She had simply learnt to carry two worlds within herself: one that
demanded intellectual rigour, professional excellence and public engagement,
and another that required an inexhaustible reservoir of patience, tenderness
and unconditional love.
It was one of those evenings when Neela could
no longer keep her anxieties to herself. She was sitting with Subrata, her
childhood friend, someone before whom she had never felt the need to pretend.
They had known each other long enough for silence to be as meaningful as
conversation.
"Subrata, do you know what frightens me
most?" she began, staring absently at her cup of tea. "It isn't what
will happen tomorrow, or even what will happen five years from now. It is what
will happen when ma and I are no longer around."
Subrata looked at her but did not interrupt.
"Nirbaan is twenty-six. He may be an
adult by the calendar, but he will always need someone to understand him, to
look after him, to make sense of a world that often makes no sense to him. My
mother has been my greatest support, but she too is growing older. What happens
when both of us are gone? Tell me, Subrata, what happens then?"
Her voice faltered.
"Is there really anything in this
country that takes care of people like Nirbaan? Not merely a place where they
can be accommodated, fed and kept out of sight. I mean somewhere they can live
with dignity, where somebody knows their names, understands their fears,
recognises their happiness and doesn't treat them as a burden. Is there a
system that will stand by them when their parents cannot?"
She paused, trying to compose herself.
"I have spent years in universities,
written papers, attended conferences in Oxford, Venice and Paris, spoken about
literature and the human condition. I can discuss Molière and Bengali theatre
with scholars across the world. But when it comes to my own son's future, I
feel utterly helpless. What good are all my degrees if I cannot answer the
simplest question a mother can ask: who will look after my child when I am
gone?"
The tears came before she could stop them.
Subrata leaned forward. "Neela, listen
to me. You are asking a question that every parent of a child with lifelong
support needs should be able to ask of society. It should not depend on how
educated the parents are, how much money they have or whether they happen to
know the right people. Care cannot be a privilege. It has to be a
responsibility."
Neela wiped her eyes. "Beautiful words,
Subrata. But where is that responsibility? Where do I find it? I don't want
Nirbaan to spend the rest of his life being passed from one institution to
another. I don't want him to become somebody's charitable obligation. He has
feelings, preferences, little pleasures. He laughs, he remembers, he waits.
Sometimes he waits for a father who has forgotten him. Must he spend the rest
of his life waiting for people who may never come?"
Subrata was quiet for a moment.
"Perhaps we have been looking at the
question from the wrong end," he said. "We keep asking who will take
care of these children. Perhaps we should begin by asking why society has not
created a world in which they can belong. Nirbaan does not need pity, Neela. He
needs acceptance, continuity and security. He needs people who will see him as
a person, not as a diagnosis. And he needs a future that does not disappear
with yours."
"But can we build such a future?"
"Not in a day. And certainly not through
promises. We need to think about supported living, trained caregivers,
financial security, legal safeguards and, most importantly, a community that
will not abandon him. We must make arrangements while we still have the
strength to do so. Love is not only about protecting someone today. Sometimes
it is about preparing the world that will receive them tomorrow."
Neela looked at him.
"I have never been afraid of hard work,
Subrata. I have worked for everything I have achieved. But this is different. I
cannot write a research paper on Nirbaan's future. I cannot defend it before an
academic panel. I cannot even guarantee that the people who promise to care
will remain."
Subrata reached for his cup.
"Then don't try to solve the rest of his
life tonight. But don't give up asking the question either. And don't mistake
your helplessness for failure. You have given him something no institution can
provide by itself: the certainty that he is loved. Now we must find a way to
make that love endure beyond your lifetime."
For a long while, neither spoke.
Outside, the evening had settled into
darkness. Neela was still worried, perhaps more than before, because the
questions had finally acquired words. But something had changed. For the first
time, she had spoken aloud the fear she had carried silently for years.
And Subrata had not offered her consolation.
He had offered her something more valuable: the possibility that Nirbaan's
future could be a collective responsibility rather than a mother's solitary
burden.
There was one absence she could never
entirely fill.
Nirbaan still spoke of his father. Perhaps he
remembered him; perhaps he had constructed an image of him from fragments of an
earlier childhood. Sometimes, when Neela was occupied with her papers or
preparing for a lecture, he would sit by himself, talking softly. His
conversations often seemed to belong to a world where time had not moved on,
where fathers did not leave and where promises were not forgotten.
Neela found Nirbaan unusually at ease with
the monkeys of Bhagalpur. He would never be scared of them like he would be
with friends his age. One evening, in the quiet of the house of Bhagalpur,
Neela heard him speaking.
"Baba, where are you? Don't you have
time to talk to me?"
There was a pause.
Then, in a voice that seemed to come from
somewhere deep within his own little world, Nirbaan answered for his father.
"Later."
And the word hung in the silence.
Later.
The one word that had perhaps defined his
father's absence, and the one word that Nirbaan, even at twenty-six, was still
waiting to hear turn into a conversation.